Well, I just finished watching the second Jane Eyre movie I've ever
seen. It confirms the fact that BBC productions are often better than
ones released in the theatre.
Here's the IMDB record for the first one I saw, with Samantha Morton, aka Agatha the Precog from Minority Report -
Jane Eyre (TV 1997)And here's the record for the one I just watched, directed by Franco Zeffirelli and with, um, some chick as Jane -
Jane Eyre (1996)The
thing about the Zeffirelli version was that it had really nifty
supporting cast. Mrs. Fairfax was played by Joan Plowright, who is in
everything.
Holy crap, she SO played Viola AND Sebastian in a 1969 TV version of
Twelfth Night. Wannit. Also, St. John Rivers was played by
Horatio Hornblower's own Major Edrington.
But, this being a real movie-type deal, they did a ton of really wacky
stuff with the plot to make it more OMGDRAMATIC. For example, when Jane
was a chibi at the boarding school, some random girl didn't have to cut
her hair - Helen Burns, the only other important kid, had to. And Jane
did too for, like, solidarity purposes or something. And the teacher in
the book who was mean because the headmistress, and the very kind
headmistress in the book became just a lowly teacher.
St. John,
amused as I was about him being Edrington, showed up way before he was
supposed to, and you never found out that he was Jane's cousin. Jane
didn't wander off into the moors and collapse nearly dead after she ran
away from Rochester, she returned to her now-deceased aunt's house,
which... I firmly believe she would have never gone back to.
Mostly
I was giving it the old raised eyebrow because the girl who played Jane
was really rather ugly, and while I know Jane isn't supposed to be
pretty... my petty human vanity made me go "bwah!" She's British by
birth, I guess, and by accent in this movie, but all the movies she's
in have been French except one or two. Anna Paquin played young Jane,
and was very good. Did you know she does the voice of Sheeta in the dub
of Laputa?
Also, they cast William Hurt as Rochester O.o And
while I don't have anything against William Hurt in particular... he
was completely passionless and had zero presence in this movie. He also
was lacking the whole dark-eyed thing, and his hair was rather light.
But nobody ever sticks to how people are described in the book. The
other Rochester, while ugly as hell, was incredibly charismatic and
passionate and had all the presence you could want. He was apparently
also in Oscar and Lucinda, which is one of the weirdest movies I've
ever seen. Had Ralph Fiennes in.
So, there we go. We also got
to see Bertha Mason's demise, but she didn't set herself on fire...
which defeats, like, half the symbolism in the entire book.
I love not having class ^_^ Time to do some dishes.